Elliott State Forest – Who would believe this???
The Elliott State Forest in Southwestern Oregon is a sad
reminder of how far off center public forest management has become. The
Elliott, once the quintessential managed forest boasting spectacular, rugged
scenery and home to a world class Douglas fir forest, is now destined to be
mired in bureaucratic gridlock as elected officials have punted on a rational
solution to this unique forest.
Previously, the Elliott provided millions of dollars to
Oregon’s Common School Fund while generating a once reliable supply of timber
for local forest product manufacturers and loggers. This resulted in thousands
of family-wage local jobs.
The Perfect Storm of environmentalist litigation,
bureaucratic incompetence and timid elected officials led to the current
situation that has the State of Oregon selling $100 million in bonds to pay for
half the value of the Elliott to the Common School Fund.
Meanwhile, the State Land Board, the Constitutional manager
of the Elliott, has retained the Department of Forestry, ODF, to negotiate a
Habitat Conservation Plan, HCP, with the US Fish & Wildlife Service and the
National Marine Fisheries Service. Wait, isn’t that how we got here?
ODF spent ten years in a failed try to negotiate an HCP with
the Federal agencies. The futile effort led the SLB of John Kitzhaber, Kate
Brown and Ted Wheeler to give up on the effort and adopt a modified Endangered
Species Act strategy which led to litigation. The Department of Justice surrendered
without a fight and paid the environmental non-profits $400,000.
The lack of timber revenue led to a failed attempt to sell
the Elliott in order to meet their responsibilities to the CSF by the Kitzhaber-Brown-Wheeler
SLB. Governor Kate Brown and new Treasurer Tobias Read flipped flopped over and
over enough to torpedo the sale to Lone
Rock Resources the only bidder for the $220.8 million Elliott.
Now we have Oregon spending twice as much in bonds to pay
the CSF for half of the Elliott, all the while for a forest it already owns. It
is only believable if own has witnessed the decades of twists and turns over
the Elliott.
Let’s not forget that the Oregon State University School of
Forestry is trying to raise $120 million to pay for the balance of the Elliott.
Forestry Dean Thomas Maness wants to turn the once hard-working Elliott into a
research/experimental forest to explore forest management and endangered
species relationships.
Meanwhile, the CSF is on the hook for the forest and road
management costs and fire protection assessments as ODF again tries to
negotiate and implement an HCP. As we have seen for the past 25 years, nothing
with the Elliott happens quickly. Stay tuned.
Bob Zybach:
ReplyDeleteThe headline is right -- the escalating incompetence of our elected officials in managing State forestlands is "unbelievable." This "plan" makes no sense. The Elliott is held in trust for Oregon's school children. And now the State is trying to get out of their legal obligation by borrowing a $100 million to "purchase" an estimated $400 million in assets and then make the children (and their parents) pay it back! Wow. Unbelievable.
This editorial only touches the surface of how Oregon's State forestlands have been mismanaged and devalued over the past 30 years by our 3-member State Land Board and our State Board of Forestry. This has been a dream for "sue-and-settle" environmental lawyers and the firms and organizations they represent, and an absolute disaster for our forests, schools, and rural timber-based economies. And our rural families and infrastructures.
In December the Governor claimed to be interested in rural Coos and Douglas county jobs and called for "new and innovative solutions" to her failed attempt to sell the Elliott. Wayne Giesy and I submitted a proposal through our 501 c(3) rural nonprofit organization, Oregon Websites & Watersheds Project, Inc., that produced $460 million for our schools over 20 years, created an estimated 430 jobs almost immediately, provided 35,000 acres specific to spotted owl and marbled murrelet habitat, only lasted 20 years, and provided paid research opportunities to OSU at no cost. Our proposal was completely ignored.
Instead, all logging has been halted on the Elliott and local Coos and Douglas county employees have been replaced by two Lane County contract "caretakers" while the federal government is given free rein to further fragment the forest through mathematical modeling programs designed to enhance spotted owl and marbled murrelet populations. And they -- not our schools -- are being given more than $6 million to do this.
This is truly unbelievable. It is time to upgrade the Board of Forestry to include actual experienced foresters and to replace the State Land Board (established in 1859) with a functional Board of Trustees that will manage our State Lands as intended by law. In the meantime, we are still attempting to move forward with our December proposal to the Governor in hopes that common sense and proven experience will ultimately prevail over costly and nonsensical politics: http://www.orww.org/Elliott_Forest/index.html